Sunday, July 14, 2019

Fermi: Overwhelmed By Problems And The Complexity of the Plant

Update July 15

The below list comes from the back of the inspection report. So Fermi identified severe corrosion in the 2018 outage and they put in a "WO" (work order)to fix the it. I highlighted in red the titles.

Check out all the cards on the CDRM system? The control rod drive system scrams, shutdowns and starts up the plant. The extent of the CDRM troubles is startling!!!!  

***May 9, 2019

DOCUMENTS REVIEWED 
 71111.04—Equipment Alignment  
 - Design Basis Document for the Control Air System; Revision C  
- Drawing 6M721–2084; Residual Heat Removal Division 1; Revision BP  
- Drawing 6M721–5730–3; Non-Interruptible Control Air System Division I and II; Revision AL  
- Drawing 6M721 
–5734; Emergency Diesel Generator Functional Operating Sketch; Revision BG  
- Drawing 6M721N–2049; P&ID Diesel Fuel Oil System and Lube Oil System Division II RHR Complex; Revision AV  
- Drawing 6M721N 
–2052; Process and Identification Residual Heat Removal Service Water System Division 1 RHR Complex; Revision AE  
- Procedure 23.208; RHR Complex Service Water Systems; Revision 122  
- Procedure 23.307; Emergency Diesel Generator System; Revisions 125 and 126 

- Procedure 24.202.05; HPCI System Cold Shutdown Valve Operability Test; Revision 50 
71111.05AQ—Fire Protection Annual/Quarterly 
 - CARD 19–21289; NQA Audit 19–0102 Deficiency  
— Required Gear Not Staged Properly for the Fire Brigade Dress Out Areas; 02/19/2019 - CARD 19 
–21870; Request Chemical Storage Areas Inventory and Hazards be Implemented into Fire Protection Pre Plans; 03/11/2019  
- Drawing 6A721–2031; Radwaste Building 1st Floor Plan Elevation 583’6”; Revision AD - Drawing 6A721 
–2033; Radwaste Building 2nd Floor Plan Elevation 613’6” and 2nd Floor Mezzanine Elevation 628’6”; Revision AC  
- Fire Drill Evaluation LP–FP–940–06YX; 1st Floor RAD Waste Chemistry Lab Storage Room Elevation 583’6”; Revision 1  
- MOP10; Fire Brigade; Revision 10  
- MRP09; Respiratory Protection; Revision 15A  
- Procedure 20.000.22; Plant Fires; Revision 46A  
- Procedure 65.000.768; Inspection of MSA Firehawk M–7 Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus; Revision 5 - Procedure FP 
–RDWST; Radwaste Building Zones 22, 23, 24, and 25; Revision 6  
- WO 52580752; Perform Unannounced Fire Drill; 03/07/2019
 71111.06—Flood Protection Measures  
 - CARD 19–21537; Missed Classification and Initial Notification During an As Found Assessment; 02/28/2019 - SS–OP–904–1901; Fermi 2 Evaluation Scenario; Revision 0 
 71111.11—Licensed Operator Requalification Program and Licensed Operator Performance 
 - CARD 19–21547; N3021C013, Number Five Low Pressure Intercept Valves Unitized Actuator Oil Temperature High; 02/28/2019  
- Procedure 22.000.03; Power Operation 25% to 100% to 25%; Revisions 103A and 104 
- Procedure 23.107; Reactor Feedwater and Condensate Systems; Revision 146  
- Procedure 23.109; Turbine Operating Procedure; Revision 94  
- Reactivity Maneuvering Plan; February 2019 Major RPA; Revision 0  
 71111.12—Maintenance Effectiveness  
 - CARD 14–23623; Maintenance Rule Expert Panel Placed C1107 in (a)(1) Status; 04/24/2014  
- CARD 14–23625; System Monitoring Under Maintenance Rule Program Identified Adverse Trend of PIP Failure; 04/24/2014 
- CARD 15–27522; Loss of RPIS Due to a Temporary Overcurrent Condition Crowbar on the C11KA01 5V Power Supply; 12-09/2015  
- CARD 18–20006; RPIS PIP Problems Identified During Suppression Testing; 01/01/2018  
- CARD 18–21250; Received 3080 ‘Control Rod Drift’ on HCU 34-03; 02/14/2018  
- CARD 18–21252; Received 3080 ‘Control Rod Drift’ on HCU 46-07; 02/14/2018  
- CARD 18–22007; CRD Accumulator Trouble HCU 26-51; 03/10/2018 
- CARD 18–22264; Received 30-17 IPCS Computer Trouble Due to Loss of MCD Data Link; 03/18/2018  
- CARD 18–23029; Control Rod 30-35 Missing Full In Light; 04/14/2018  
- CARD 18–23030; Control 42-11 has Blue Scram Light On with Only Half Scram In; 04/14/2018

- CARD 18–23122; Control Rod 18-15 Full In Light Did Not Extinguish when Rod Withdrawn; 04/17/2018  
- CARD 18–23131; Missing CRDM PIP Indications; 04/17/2018  
- CARD 18–23648; Loss of Position Indication Control Rod 42-27; 05/07/2018  
- CARD 18–23656; Control Rod Select Pushbutton for 54-23 Failing; 05/07/2018  
- CARD 18–23721; Received 3D80 ‘Control Rod Drift’ on CRD 46-07; 05/09/2018  
- CARD 18–24252; Control Rod Drift Alarm 06-15; 05/29/2018 
- CARD 18–26075; Control Rod 46-19 Briefly Lost Position 46 Indication; 08/11/2018  
- CARD 18–27225; Drift Lights for CRD 26-31 and 50-23 Do Not Indicate on the Full Core Display; 09/24/2018  
- CARD 18–27279; Control Rod 26-19 and 30-11 Missing PIPs; 09/24/2018  
- CARD 18–27324; Trend CARD — Crud Found in HCI DCV During Inspection; 09/26/2018  
- CARD 18–28185; Control Rod 26-43 Loss of Full in Light; 10/11/2018  
- CARD 18–28201; During Control Rod Exercising 38-31 Notched Out and the Full In Light Remained Illuminated; 10/12/2018  
- CARD 18–28242; CRDM 50-31 Missing PIP Indications; 10/13/2018 
- CARD 18–28253; Control Rod 26-43 Full In Light Goes Out when Lifting at Position 00; 10/13/2018 - CARD 18–28311; Control Rod 14-27; 10/14/2018  
- CARD 18–28349; CR 30-15 Became Uncoupled When Fully Withdrawn; 10/15/2018  
- CARD 18–28354; Multiple Rod Movement Message Received on RWM-OD During Performance of Scram Time Testing; 10/15/2018 
- CARD 18–28388; Control Rod 26-43 ‘ Full Out’ Light Not Lit with the Rod at Position 48; 10/16/2018  
- CARD 18–28443; 3D76 Control Rod Over-Travel for Rod 26-19; 10/17/2018  
- CARD 18–28445; 3D80 Control Rod Drift for Rod 06-23; 10/17/2018  
- CARD 18–28448; Control Rod 30-43 Missing ‘18’ Indication; 10/17/2018  
- CARD 18–28449; 50-31 Missing Various PIP Indications; 10/18/2018 
- CARD 18–28450; Control Rod 50-51 Missing Various Indications; 10/18/2018  
- CARD 18–28550; PMT Failed for Rod 18-15 WO 50495365; 10/20/2018  
- CARD 18–28588; Full In Light 42-27 Momentarily Flickered; 10/21/2018  
- CARD 18–28673; CRD 54-23 Missing Various PIP Indications; 10/24/2018  
- CARD 18–28759; Control Rod 38-19 Full In Light Lit with Rod at Position 12; 10/26/2018  
- CARD 18–28892; Control Rod Drift Alarm 06-15; 10/29/2018  
- CARD 18–28989; Control Rod Drift Alarm 58-43; 11/01/2018  
- CARD 18–29030; RONOR Switch Failed; 11/03/2018  
- CARD 18–29201; RONOR Switch Failed; 11/10/2018  
- CARD 18–29679; Received 3D80, Control Rod Drift, Alarm for Control Rod 42-19; 12/03/2018  
- CARD 18–29830; 58-23 Abnormal Indications After Scram; 12/07/2018  
- CARD 18–29862; Rod Drift 42-27; 12/08/2018  
- CARD 18–29876; Rod 26-43 Double Notch; 12/09/2018  
- CARD 18–29912; Control Rod 50-31 Missing PIPs 30, 31, 34, 35, and 38 Entering FO18–02; 12/10/2018  
- CARD 18–29914; Control Rod Drift 58-23; 12/10/2018  
- CARD 18–29915; Control Rod Drift 06-23; 12/10/2018  
- CARD 18–29954; RONOR Switch is Working Intermittently when Placed in Override; 12/11/2018  
- CARD 18–30119; Control Rod Drift Alarm Received for Rod 46-55; 12/14/2018  
- CARD 18–30228; Rod 46-19 Received a Rod Drift Alarm while Moving from Position 00 to 02; 12/19/2018  
- CARD 18–30342; AB5/RB5 Secondary Containment Airlock Door will Not Open; 12/22/2018

- CARD 18–30369; Door Not Allowing Access; 12/25/2018  
- CARD 19–20015; Rod Drift 06-23; 01/01/2019  
- CARD 19–20020; Rod Drift 42-19; 01/02/2019  
- CARD 19–20026; Rod Drift 26-23; 01/02/2019  
- CARD 19–20048; Control Rod Drift Alarm Rod 34-19; 01/02/2019  
- CARD 19–20054; Rod Drift 06-15; 01/03/2019  
- CARD 19–20462; Control Rod 18-59 Full Out Indication Light Remained Lit When Driven to Position 46; 01/19/2019  
- CARD 19–20465; Received Rod for Rod 50-19; 01/19/2019  
- CARD 19-20614; Control Air Compressor Room North Airlock Malfunction; 01/26/2019  
- CARD 19–20854; RMOC 2019 RMOC Action Item Tracking; 02/06/2019  
- CARD 19–21227; AB5/RB5 Interlock Switch Needs Adjustment; 02/17/2019  
- CARD 19–21292; RB5 and AB5 Airlock Doors Opened at the Same Time Resulting in a Temporary Loss of Secondary Containment; 02/19/2019  
- CARD 19-21474; MRC Cognitive Trend:  Door Airlock and Interlock Malfunction; 02/26/2019  
- LCO Tracking Sheet 2018-0267C; Secondary Containment Doors Without Interlocks; 06/26/2018  
- Maintenance Rule Conduct Manual, Appendix E, Maintenance Rule SSC Specific Functions; Revision 23A  
- Maintenance Rule Conduct Manual, Appendix F, Maintenance Rule Performance Criteria; Revision 21  
- Procedure 23.428; Secondary Containment Airlocks and Penetrations; Revision 35A 
- Procedure 24.000.01, Situational Surveillances/LCO Action Tracking; Revision 77  
- Procedure MGA03, Chapter 3, Procedure Use and Adherence; Revision 27A  
- WO 48136887; Perform Reactor/Aux Building Airlock Interlock Verification Test; 12/02/2018  
- WO 51444881; Restore Normal Operation to RB4/RB3 Interlock Doors; 08/01/2018  
- WO 52890935; Investigate/Repair RB5 Reactor/Aux Building Airlock Interlock Not Functioning; 01/04/2019 
 71111.13—Maintenance Risk Assessments and Emergent Work Control 
 - CARD 19–20212; RPS Relay C71A-K10B Deenergized; 01/09/2019  
- CARD 19–20214; 1 HPCV Low Pressure Light Did Not Illuminate; 01/10/2019  
- CARD 19–20215; Erratic Reading on 2 HPCV Indicator; 01/10/2019  
- CARD 19–21375; Enhancement to ODE-20 (Protected Equipment) for Protecting CREF Equipment; 02/21/2019  
- CARD 19–21711; WO D302210100, Refurbish West Circulation Water Makeup Pump P4100C011.  After Tagging, it was Discovered that Isolation had Not Been Achieved; 03/06/2019 
- Drawing 6I721–2040–07; Arrangement Trip System ‘B’ RPS Cabinet H11P611; Revision R  
- Drawing 6I721–2155–06; Reactor Protection System Trip System ‘A’ System Relays;  Revision V  
- Drawing 6I721–2155–07; Reactor Protection System Trip System ‘B’ System Relays; Revision X  
- Drawing 6I721–2155–09; Reactor Protection System Trip System ‘B’ Scram Trip Logic; Revision L  
- Drawing 6I721–2155–09A; RPS Trip System ‘B2’ Scram Trip Logic; Revision D  
- Drawing 6M721–5720; Circulating Water System Functional Operating Sketch; Revision BC  
- Drawing 6M721–5726; General Service Water System Functional Operating Sketch; Revision CG 

- Maintenance Rule Conduct Manual MMR12; Equipment Out of Service Risk Management; Revision 20  
- Procedure 23.101; Circulating Water System; Revision 103 
- Procedure 23.610; Reactor Protection System; Revision 24 
- Procedure 24.110.05; RPS — Turbine Control and Stop Valve Functional Test; Revision 47  
- Procedure 44.010.064; RPS — Turbine Stop Valve Limit Switch Closure Calibration; Revision 33  
- Risk Management Plan, EDG 14 Safety System Outage; 02/20/2019  
- WO 52936137; RPS Relay C71A-K10B De-energized; 01/10/2019 
- WO D302210100; Refurbish West Circulation Water Makeup Pump; 03/05/2019
 71111.15—Operability Determinations and Functionality Assessments  
- CARD 19-20353; Mispositioned Component APRM 3 Not Bypassed during 45.604.001; 01/16/2019  
- CARD 19–20871; 9D18 Division 1 48/24V Battery 21A Trouble Due to Low Voltage; 02/06/2019  
- CARD 19–20951; Trip of 24/48 Volt Battery Charger 21A-2 and Erratic Division 1 IRM Recorder Readings; 02/08/2019  
- CARD 19–20965; Prompt Investigation IAW MGA23 for Trip of Division 1 48/24 Volt Battery Charger; 02/08/2019  
- CARD 19–21475; Abnormal Reactor Building Sump Input/Lifting RHRSW Relief Valve  Division 2; 02/26/2019  
- CARD 19–21535; RHRSW Thermal Relief Valve Lifted; 02/28/2019  
- Drawing 6SD721–2530–17; One Line Diagram 48/24 VDC Instrumentation Batteries Distribution; Revision AM  
- EFA–E11–19–001; E1100F056B Division 2 RHR Heat Exchanger Tube Side Relief Valve Stuck Open; 03/01/2019  
- MQA11–100; Operability Determination Process; Revision 2A 
- Procedure 20.300.24/48 VDC; Loss of 24/48V DC Battery Busses; Revision 2 - Procedure 23.310; 48/24 VDC Electrical System; Revision 29  
- Procedure 23.601; Instrument Trip Sheets; Revision 40 - Procedure 24.000.02; Shiftly, Daily, and Weekly Required Surveillances; Revision 154  
- Procedure 44.030.056; ECCS — Reactor Recirculation Riser DP, Division 1, Functional Test; Revision 30  
- Procedure 45.604.001; LPRM Testing and Preparation for Removal; Revision 47 - Procedure 57.000.10; LPRM Operational Status; Revision 40  
- Procedure ARP 9D18; Division 1 48/24 VDC Battery 21A Trouble; Revision 13 - TE–R32–19–008; Past Operability Review of Division 1 24/48 Volt Batteries; Revision 0  
- WO 49664080; Perform IV Curves on APRM 3 LPRM Detectors; 01/18/2018
 71111.19—Post Maintenance Testing  
- CARD 19-21301; EDG 14 Air Coolant Pump Backlash; 02/19/2019  
- CARD 19–21308; During Cross-Drive Contingency Implementation, Flex Drive Gear Teeth Found Significantly Fretted and Pitted; 02/20/2019  
- CARD 19–21333; Missing Parts from EDG Flex Gear Kit; 02/20/2019 
- CARD 19–21479; Relief Valve E1100F056B Lost its Traceability After RF19; 02/26/2019  
- Drawing 6I721N–2201–50; Mechanical Draft Cooling Tower Fan ‘A’ High and Low Breaker Cont. E1156C001A; Revision W  
- Procedure 24.208.03; EESW and EECW Makeup Pump and Valve Operability Test; Revision 81  
- Procedure 24.307.17, Emergency Diesel Generator 14-Start and Load Test; Revision 5 
- Procedure 24.307.48; Emergency Diesel Generator 14-Fast Start Followed by Load Reject; Revision 15  
- Procedure 35.000.237; Alignment of Vertical Equipment; Enclosure B  
- Procedure 35.307.008; Emergency Diesel Generator-Engine General Maintenance;  Revision 44  
- Procedure 35.318.009; Inspection and Testing of ITE Ground and Overcurrent Protection Relays Revision 32  
- Procedure 46.000.105; ITT General Control Milliampere Hydramotor Actuator Model 91; Revision 28  
- Residual Heat Removal Complex HVAC Design Basis Document 
- WO 48522230, Perform 24.307.48 EDG 14 Fast Start Followed by Load Reject; 02/25/19  
- WO 49005245; Perform 24.208.03 D2 EECW M/U Pump and Valve Operability (Section 5.2); 03/28/2019  
- WO 51526965; Refurbish RHR HVAC EDG-14 Room Return Air Damper Actuator; 02/18/2019 
 71111.20—Refueling and Other Outage Activities  
 - CARD 19–20217; Fatigue Management Violation Associated with Torus Coating Activities; 01/10/2019  
- MGA17; Working Hour Limits; Revisions 10A and 11  
- MMR Appendix E; Maintenance Rule SSC Specific Functions; Revision 23A  
- Procedure 22.000.02; Plant Startup to 25% Power; Revision 101  
- Procedure 23.109; Turbine Operating Procedure; Revision 94  
- Procedure 23.118; Main Generator and Generator Excitation; Revision 67  
- WO 48693770; Extensive Coating Defects Identified During Torus Underwater Inspection; 09/22/2018  
- WO 48693800; Inspect and Repair Torus Coating, Above Water; 09/18/2017 
 71111.22—Surveillance Testing 
 - Procedure 24.137.01; Main Steam Line Isolation Channel Functional Test; Revision 46 
- WO 47498965; Perform 44.010.062 RPS MSIV’s Inboard Valve Limit Switch, Divisions I and II, CAL; 10/09/2018  
- WO 49253018; Perform 24.137.01 Main Steam Line Isolation Valve Channel Functional Test; 03/02/2019  
 71114.06—Drill Evaluation 
 - RERP Plan Implementing Procedure EP-101; Classification of Emergencies; Revision 42C  
 71151—Performance Indicator Verification  
 - LER 2018-002-00; Loss of Division 1 Offsite Power Causes Partial Loss of Feedwater Leading to ECCS Injection and Reactor Scram; 06/12/2018  
- LER 2018-006-00; Emergency Diesel Generator Load Sequencer Inhibits Automatic Start of Residual Heat Removal Pumps Under Certain Scenarios Due to Unrecognized Original Design Defect; 12/14/2018

- Licensee PI Data Submittal Reports for Scrams/Scrams with Complications, January 2018December 2018  
- Licensee PI Data Submittal Reports for Unplanned Power Changes, January 2018- December 2018  
- Licensing Performance Indicator Safety System Functional Failure CDE Data Entry, Verification and Approval Reports: February 2018 and September 2018  
71152—Problem Identification and Resolution 
 - CARD 17–27506; The MDCT Brake Inverter Panel, R1700S011B, is Indicating No AC Volts or AC Amps and the AC Power Light is Off; 09/09/2017  
- CARD 18–25847; Division 2 MDCT Fan Brake Inverter Found with No Power; 08/03/2018  
- CARD 18–27984; AECOM Threatened to be Laid Off if They Write a CARD; 10/08/2018  
- CARD 18–29027; E1150F068B Did Not Close as Expected; 11/02/2018  
- CARD 18–29322; Potential Issue with E1150F068A Noted by Abnormal System Response for RHRSW Pump ‘A’ Startup; 11/16/2018  
- CARD 18–29727; The MDCT Brake Inverter Panel, R1700S011B, is Indicating No AC Volts or AC Amps and the AC Power Light is Off; 12/04/2018  
- CARD 18–29745; Evaluate Vendor Suggested MDCT Inverter Replacement; 12/04/2018  
- CARD 19–20118; NQA Evaluate Adding Reference to NRC Information Notice 85-89 to Item Descriptions for Fabrication of 410 Stainless Steel Valve Stems; 01/04/2019 
- CARD 19–20217; Fatigue Management Violation Associated with Torus Coating Activities; 01/10/2019  
- CARD 19–20652; Provide Additional Training/Information Regarding the Purpose and Value of the Site Corrective Action Process; 01/29/2019 
- CARD 19–21516; 27.2019-5 Recorded Triggers on Division II by the Astromed Monitoring the Division 2 MDCT Inverter; 02/27/2019  
- LER 2016–006–00; Inadequate Interpretation of Technical Specifications Related to Mechanical Draft Cooling Tower Fan Brake System Leads to Condition Prohibited by Technical Specifications, Loss of Safety Function, and Unanalyzed Condition; 10/20/2016  
- LER 2017–005–00; Non-Functional Mechanical Draft Cooling Tower Fan Brakes Leads to HPCI Being Declared Inoperable and Loss of Safety Function; 11/03/2017  
- LER 2018–005–0; Non-Functional Mechanical Draft Cooling Tower Fan Brakes Leads to HPCI Being Declared Inoperable and Loss of Safety Function; 09/29/2018  
- LER 89–016–00; Residual Heat Removal Service Water Cooling Tower Fan Brake Inoperable Due to Low Nitrogen Pressure; 07/11/1989  
- Procedure 35.000.235; Bolted Bonnet Globe Valve General Maintenance; Revision 29 - Procedure 46.205.001; Calibration of RHR Cooling Tower Fan Overspeed Protection System; Revision 30  
 71153—Follow-Up of Events and Notices of Enforcement Discretion  
- CARD 18–28572; Degraded Grid Relaying is Not Bypassed when the EDGs are Supplying their Respective ESF Bus; 10/20/2018  
- CARD 18–28990; Root Cause Evaluation Identified that EDP 80065 Inadvertently Changed 4160V ‘6’ Close Permissive; 11/01/2018  
- LER 2018–005–0; Non-Functional Mechanical Draft Cooling Tower Fan Brakes Leads to HPCI Being Declared Inoperable and Loss of Safety Function; 09/29/2018 

- LER 2018–006–00; Emergency Diesel Generator Load Sequencer Inhibits Automatic Start of Residual Heat Removal Pumps Under Certain Scenarios Due to Unrecognized Original Design Defect; 10/19/2018 - Operating Logs; 8/2/2018 – 08/05/

No comments: